'Still' Good: Julianne Moore struggles to hold on to memories. |
There’s a thrilling moment in “Still Alice” in which the
title character, Alice Howland (Julianne Moore, in her Oscar-winning performance),
has just finished one of her frequent runs on the campus of Columbia University,
where she works as a linguistics professor. The imagery in this early scene
unfolds like a puzzle—if you didn’t already know that the movie was about a
character dealing with a diagnosis of early-onset familial Alzheimer’s disease,
it might be fun to guess.
As the scene continues, Alice stops and breathlessly
surveys her surroundings, which appear as a hazy blur in the distance. Cut to a
shot of Alice, whose initial expression of surprise crosses into fear as the
camera begins to slowly swirl around her. It’s only after a few deep breaths
that the world, literally, comes back into focus. For the brainy Alice, who’s only
50 and not accustomed to being lost, the thought of suddenly being cornered in
a confused fog is highly disconcerting.
From this point, the fact that the film’s look settles
down into something familiar and routine is a bit of a letdown. In cinema when
the subject is illness, there’s a lot of latitude to be visually
ambitious—Ingmar Bergman’s “Cries and Whispers” comes to mind—but co-directors
Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland (who also teamed up to write the
screenplay, from a novel of the same name by Lisa Genova) take a mostly bland,
televisual approach.
While imperfect, “Still Alice” remains effective and has
a lot to appreciate, namely the performances. Besides Moore’s
characteristically impressive work, there’s Alec Baldwin as her loving but
career-minded husband John, a doctor struggling to balance caring for his wife
with new job opportunities; Kristen Stewart in a sharp turn as Lydia, youngest
of two daughters and an aspiring actress who eventually moves back home from
California to look after her mom; and Kate Bosworth, underused as older
daughter Anna, who learns she has the gene to eventually inherit her mother’s
disease but is oddly left on the fringes of the story.
Much of the film chronicles various stages of Alice’s
illness. There are good days, such as a lovely scene in which Alice and Lydia
go for a walk at a beach on Long Island and mom acts like her old self,
needling Lydia about going college and having a back-up plan in case acting
doesn’t work out; and bad days, such as a heartbreaking scene where Alice
frantically searches at home for the bathroom and freezes in panic when she
can’t find it.
There is unexpected humor, too, such as when Alice pouts
about reading the same page of “Moby Dick” over and over. John suggests
something lighter and Alice, in a moment of hilarious, self-deprecating clarity
quips, “What, like ‘The Cat it the Hat?’” Ultimately, “Still Alice” seems less
a story about disease than a story about a family’s commitment and love for
each another.
There are some moments of manipulative melodrama—planning
ahead, Alice uploads a video to herself with instructions on taking a bottle of
sleeping pills for when she gets too sick, and inevitably stumbles upon it
later—but otherwise the film is careful about being too preachy or exploiting
the circumstances for false sentiment and maudlin payoffs. Perhaps the most
genuinely moving scene occurs when Alice gives a speech on Alzheimer’s at a
medical convention and her voice quakes when she talks about her love of
communication.
Indeed, it’s a sad irony that much of Alice’s life and success
has to do with a fascination with words, and that by the end she has almost
none of them left to say.